BonFX

Typography & Graphic Design Blog

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Blog
  • Books
    • The Preposterously Huge Book of Google Font Combinations
    • The Big Book of Font Combinations (Classic Fonts Edition)
  • About
  • Contact
  • Store
You are here: Home / Web Design / Redesign of nbcnews.com gives “mobile-first” strategy a black eye

Redesign of nbcnews.com gives “mobile-first” strategy a black eye

February 5, 2014 by Douglas Bonneville

Visit nbcnews.com now. The “news” site has 5 headlines. I’m on a Mac with a 1080p display. This is what 5 headlines on a 1080p display looks like:

news

This is what happens when someone doesn’t get mobile-first.

Mobile-first should mean optimizing the content and design starting with mobile, not starting and ending with mobile. I’m looking at a formerly desktop-friendly news site that is 100% unusable on a desktop device.

This is such a goofy misapplication of mobile-first methodology that it’s goofy.

Let me just say that I wrote a little piece called 52 Question Checklist for Responsive Web Design Projects that was written to prevent goofy misapplications of mobile-first, or responsive web design, exactly like what we see at nbcnews.com. It annoyed a few people. I wonder if any of those people are on the design team at nbcnews.com?

Ok, so the world should design websites mobile-first. We get it. It’s right. It’s “how to build websites” now. But someone in charge of nbcnews.com only read the table of contents to “Mobile-First Web Design for Dummies” (is that a real book?), stopped there, not realizing they didn’t get it. This is Windows 8 all over again. Truly mobile paradigms are….mobile! They don’t translate to desktops! Hasn’t anyone on the design team at nbcnews.com been paying attention…to anything?

Oh well, another day, another deleted bookmark to a formerly relevant or usable site.

BTW: Don’t even click “Search” unless YOU ARE READY FOR SOME SERIOUS SEARCHING! WOOHOO!

You clicked “Search”, didn’t you. You were warned.

 

Filed Under: Web Design

About Douglas Bonneville

Douglas has been a graphic designer since 1992, in addition to software developer and author. He is a member of Smashing Magazine's "Panel of Experts" and has contributed to over 100 articles. He is the author of "The Big Book of Font Combinations", loves cats, and plays guitar.

Comments

  1. Spencer Steel says

    February 5, 2014 at 2:27 pm

    The funniest part about the Windows 8 resemblance is that I believe NBC News.com recently RID themselves of the last vestiges of their Microsoft partnership. So that they could transform one of the very best websites on the net into an unusable one. After sixteen years, I’ve just changed my homepage to CNN and there’s no way I’m alone in having done that.

  2. Douglas Bonneville says

    February 5, 2014 at 3:01 pm

    One thing I’ve learned on the web is that when a website dies, just move on. Don’t even grieve. Just move on. Greats sites, once they have an epic misfire, rarely if ever resurrect to any semblance of former glory. Look at Digg. What is that now? Some sites handle changes in user paradigm well, and they survive to see the next change. Some sites miss it big time and never come back.

    There is something desperate in this volley for trendiness that missed the point of the trend – greater usability, focus on content, greater readability. It tossed all that out the window.

    It’s also ironic that the most boring if not ugly site in the whole world sits by, works on any platform, ignores all the trends, hasn’t changed in 15 years, is the number one news aggregator, has tiny pictures, yet remains front and center on desktops and smartphones worldwide, etc.: Drudgereport.com

Drink from your favorite Font Mug

HOW TO MAKE INSPIRED FONT COMBINATIONS (without spending all day clicking things).


Font Combinations Book  

On Sale Now
Amazon / B&N

Or get the PDF eBook version, INSTANT ACCESS, 40% off Retail, now at the BonFX Store

Subscribe to the BonFX Newsletter

Keep tabs on the latest typography and design books and apps from BonFX. If you subscribe today, we'll also send you the classic "Typography Primer" from Adobe!

Recent Inspirations

  • The Preposterously Huge Book of Font Combinations January 13, 2021
  • Rainer Maria Rilke June 2, 2020
  • Three secrets to ignite inspiration April 22, 2020
  • How to “Draw Out” Your Creativity March 27, 2020
  • Finding Your Voice as an Artist: The Paradox of Originality February 18, 2020
  • Artist Frederick Franck on Seeing February 15, 2020
  • How to Move Beyond Creative Blocks February 10, 2020
  • Claude Bernard: The Only Way to Learn June 25, 2019
  • Negative Space: Saying A Lot With Nothing June 25, 2019
  • Shadowy Black and White Watercolors by Artist Elicia Edijanto June 18, 2019
  • Copland on What Creativity is Not June 18, 2019
  • Ornate Leaf Sculpture and Crochet Art by Susanna Bauer June 18, 2019
  • How to choose from among all your great ideas June 17, 2019
  • What you see is not always what you are looking at June 14, 2019
  • The Key to Unleashing Your Natural Creativity June 14, 2019

Copyright © 2021 · BonFX